What Are You?

What Are You?


Are you your body? Well, kind of, right? But, is there a line
where this stops being true? How much of yourself can you remove
before you stop being you, and does the question even make sense? Your physical existence is cells,
trillions of them, at least ten times more
than there are stars in the Milky Way. A cell is a living being, a machine made
of up to 50 thousand different proteins. It has no consciousness, no will,
no purpose; it just is, but it is still an individual. Together, your cells form huge structures
for jobs like preparing food, gathering resources,
transporting stuff around, scanning the environment,
and so on. If you extract cells from your body
and put them in the right environment, they will continue to
stay alive for a while, so your cells can exist without you,
but you can’t exist without them. If we take all the cells away,
there is no “you” anymore. Is there a line where
a pile of your cells stops being you? For example, if you donate an organ,
billions of your cells will continue to live on inside someone else. Does this mean that a part of you
became a part of another person, or is this other body
keeping a part of you alive? Or, let us imagine an experiment: you and a random person
from the street exchange cells. One at a time, your body
gets one of their cells; their body gets
one of your cells. At which point would they become you? Would they ever, or is this just
a very slow and gross way to teleport you? Let’s make this more complicated! The image of ourselves as
a static thing is untenable. Almost all of your cells have to die
during your lifetime. Two hundred and fifty million have died
since the beginning of this video, alone, between one and three million per second. In a seven-year period, most of your cells
are replaced at least once. Every time your cells’ setup changes,
you are slightly different than before, so a part of you is dying constantly. If you are lucky enough to become old, you would have cycled through roughly
a million billion cells, so what you consider yourself
is really just a snapshot, but sometimes, cells are broken
and don’t want to die questioning the very nature
of the unity of our bodies. We call them cancer. They cancel
the biological social contract and become basically immortal. Cancer is not an outside invader; it’s a part of you that
puts its own survival over yours, but you could also argue that a cancer
cell becomes another entity inside us; another being that just wants to
thrive and survive. Can we blame it for that? A chilling cell story is that of
Henrietta Lacks, a young cancer patient who died in 1951. Usually, cells only survived
for a few days in the lab, making research very hard. Henrietta’s cancer cells were immortal. Over the decades, they were multiplied
over and over again and used for countless research projects
saving countless lives. Henrietta’s cells are still alive
and overall have been grown to at least 20 tons of biomass, so there are living parts around the world
from someone who has been considered dead for decades. How much of Henrietta is in these cells? What makes one of
your cells “you,” anyway? Maybe the information contained in it,
your DNA? Until recently, it was believed that
all the cells in your body had basically the same genetic code, but it turns out this is wrong. Your genome is mobile,
changing over time through mutations
and environmental influences. This is especially the case in your brain. According to recent discoveries, a single
neuron in an adult brain has more than one thousand mutations in its
genetic code that are not present in the cells surrounding it,
but how much “you” is your DNA, really? About eight percent of the human genome
is made up of viruses that once infected our ancestors and merged with us. Mitochondria, power plants of the cell,
once were bacteria that merged with the ancestors of your cells.
They still have their own DNA. An average cell has hundreds of them,
hundreds of little things that are not really human,
but they still kind of are. It is confusing.
Let’s backtrack a bit. We know that you’re made up of
trillions of little things made from more little things
that are constantly changing. Together, all those little things
are not static, but dynamic. Their composition and condition
is changing constantly, so we might just be a self-sustaining
pattern without clear borders that gained self-awareness at some point
and now has the ability to think about itself
through time and space, but really only exists in
this exact very moment. Where did this pattern start: with your conception,
when the first human arose, when life first began
conquering our small planet, or when the elements that make up your
body were forged in a star? Our human brains evolved
to deal with absolutes. The fuzzy borders that make up reality
are hard to grasp. Maybe ideas like beginning and end,
life and death, you and me, are really not absolutes, but ideas
belonging to a fluent pattern; a pattern that is lost in this strange
and beautiful universe. (Shifting to the voice of CGP Grey)
The problem of who we are isn’t just a question of ourselves,
but it’s also a question of our minds. Just as our cells can be divided and
separated from us, so can our very brains be divided and separated from us
while still in the skull. Click here to go to my channel
and watch the next part. Okay, so now, go watch CGP Grey’s video. If you’re not yet subscribed
to his channel, you should really change that now. Subtitles by the Amara.org community

100 comments

  1. The human body is just a Pot to contain consciousness after death our consciousness are separated from the body and go somewhere we just don't have technology to Prove it plus We don't know exactly where in our body there is our consciousness
    The body doesn't matter what's important is
    ✅Where does our consciousness go?
    ✅where in our body there is our consciousness?

  2. My friend once asked how many parts of my bike I can replace and still have the same bike. I replied "All but the frame."
    Your torso, you are your torso.

  3. Kurzgesagt – In a Nutshell:
    *Consciousness combined with the Mind, Brain and Life Experiences, Choices and Decision Making is who you are. What you are is a physical apparatus made of Cells and Blood power by food, water and air with all these non-material essence and physical substances link together to make this functioning physical apparatus a Living Being with an Observable Mannerism, Identifiable Persona, Distinguishable Traits, idiosyncrasy, Character and Distinct Peculiarity. YOU ARE WELCOME*

  4. The most YOU/only YOU is your BRAIN which can be divided into two sections Left and Right hemisphere, works differently and if Corpus Callosum is removed works individually. Who actually are you/we? Right side or Left side or Both OR you/we are just experiencing the existence of it(Brain) through consciousness.
    Besides we don't know what consciousness is. 😖😖

  5. Can someone educated on the subject let me know; if, all of your cells were "cancer" cells(immortal) would you be able to live long. I am saying if it did not affect you leading to your death the way it does (cancer)

  6. I would say that we are a colony of dumb little micro organisms that evolved a command centra to be able to survive better (the brain) which accidently evolved what we call consciousness. The question is then, if many dumb things can create something with a consiousness, wouldn't that also maybe apply to computers? Think of all connected computers and processors. With many enough, many dumb processors might together evolve some kind of consiousness. The key to real A.I might just be large quantities of processors as well as some kind of environment to respond to.

  7. In the most bare, I am coordinates (information) of atoms in a x, y and z space. Replicate those atoms and those coordinates exactly, then you have me from that instance where my atomic coordinates were recorded.

  8. I think humanity already found out the correct answer for this long time ago, but they just don't want to recognize sad, cold truth of it so pretends there is not clear answer yet.

  9. An object defined for human record-keeping, like a ship, can have all its pieces replaced so long as it's done a small bit at a time. So long as it's still recognizable, the object assimilates any parts put into it. That's why the Ship of Theseus is still the same ship, but it wouldn't be if Theseus threw out the ship and bought another; the ship assimilates planks into itself one at a time.

  10. So what if i was cancer i would be immortal but i would never age …

    Ash is cancer or dialga stopped ash from aging or arceus wone of them or maybe all

  11. What if I go to sleep- am I still the same person as yesterday or am I just reading the stored memory of yesterday in the morning and identifying with it. Maybe the last me died last evening.

  12. (KJV)Acts 16:30-31
    And brought them out, and said, Sirs, what must I do to be saved?
    And they said, Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ, and thou shalt be saved, and thy house.
    (KJV)John 3:16 For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son,
    that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.

  13. WHAT IS OUR FUCKING PURPOSE IS IT JUST TO AND DIE TO ME MY LIFE DON'T MEAN MUCH WHAT IS THE MEETING OF LIIIIFE 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

  14. “How much of you can you remove before you stop being you?”

    Me, after beating Risk Of Rain once:

    The Expert

  15. ALL is strardust… Nothing more nothing less. Rest is an illusion. Rien ne se perd rien ne se cré tout se transforme. (Lavoisier 1634)

  16. Imagine if you could be as cool as a cancer cell. You dont want to cease to exist, so you…just dont. And become immortal.

  17. My brains way of thinking after this video;
    “How much can you remove before you stop being you”
    “Take away limbs”
    Ok still you
    “Take away body and replace blood flow with artificial blood”
    Ok Still y… wait that’s Futerama

  18. 정말 나에 대한 부분에 대해 철학적 고민을 하게하면서도 과학적으로 접근하는 방식이 흥미롭고 재밌었습니다. 좋은 영상 감사합니다 🙂

  19. Just watched a marathon of who are you type videos and I seriously am unsatisfied. I'm ganna research and see if I can get answers.

  20. Genetic code is not a genetic information about us, it is the set of rules used by cells to translate information encoded within genetic material into protein. Please dont mistake genome with genetic code 😉

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *